Wednesday, January 07, 2015

Grimm Fairy Tales







 Isaiah's "2014 Self-Exposure" went up last week and captures the Obama presidency perfectly.

I'm having non-stop problems with blogging tonight.


So instead of trying to recreate my now lost post, I'll note this by Great Britain's Socialist Worker:




Tales of Grimm justice

Writer and translator Jack Zipes spoke to Socialist Worker about the enduring popularity of the tales of the Brothers Grimm, and how they appeal to our sense of hope

Once upon a time the Brothers Grimm collected folk tales. The stories and characters are hugely familiar. 
It is well known that the tales are more bawdy and brutal than Disney cartoons. Characters sometimes live “happily to the end of their days” but they never live “ever after”.


But the scale of the difference only now becomes clear for an English language reader.



The Grimms’ Children’s and Household Tales first edition, published in German in 1812, has been translated into English for the first time by left wing scholar and translator Jack Zipes.



According to Jack, “The Grimms never intended the tales they collected to be read by children.



“The tales are about children and families, and how they reacted to the difficult conditions under which they lived.”



The stories originated as tales told by “folk”. They were passed down through generations to provide entertainment.



Jack argues that the process of making literature from non-literary traditions can be a sanitation, but not in a simplistic way.



The tales are brusque, blunt, absurd, comical and tragic. How Some Children Played at Slaughtering was cut after the first edition.



Slaughtering



It tells the tale of two boys who see their father slaughtering a pig. “They decided to play slaughtering,” explained Jack.



“One brother became the pig, and the other became the slaughterer and he slit the throat of the younger brother.



“The mother saw what happened from a window. She ran downstairs and took the knife out of the boy’s throat and, out of fury, stabbed the older boy in the heart.



Then she realised the baby was upstairs, and in the meantime the baby had died and drowned in the tub.



“She was so remorseful she committed suicide. The father was so dismayed that after two years he wasted away.”



Another tale is called The Children of Famine. A widow is starving with her two children and thinks she might have to eat them.



“The two children, two girls, do their best not to get eaten by their own mother,” said Jack. “The story ends with the children promising to lie down and sleep ‘until judgement day’. The mother departs to ‘nobody knows where’.”



Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm lived in a French-occupied Germanic area at the start of the 19th century.

They overcame poverty and their view of folklore reflects their utopian dreams.


“The Grimms wanted to preserve tales they believed emanated naturally from the German people in an oral tradition before they evaporated,” said Jack.



“They were among the first Europeans at the beginning of the nineteenth century, later called folklorists, who took a sincere interest in the culture of the common people.”



For Jack, the Grimms’ “mission” was to conserve German tales, legends, myths and other artifacts.



“In this way, they felt they might contribute to the cultural unification of German people throughout central Europe,” he added.



“We must remember there was no such thing as Germany in the early part of the nineteenth century.”

Political



Jack said there was an overtly political side to their project.



“By collecting and assembling tales that were probably told in dialect or some variant of high German, they wanted to contribute to a cultural and social sense of ‘German-ness’.



“They took the side of revolutionaries in 1848 to support political reforms. 
They published the tales in high German—not to repackage them but to make them accessible to a growing literate class.”


Originally there were 
156 stories, while the seventh edition has 210. The Grimms didn’t simply add stories over the years. They deleted, made many changes, revisions and embellishments. 

The stories morph into the more polished, puritanical, sentimental, Christian and child-friendly refinements of the bestselling later editions.



They develop a more homespun note, a more preachy bourgeois tone with an emphasis on patriarchal and middle class values.



Though even the later versions are far more gritty than subsequent retellings.


Jack said, “There were no religious tales in the first edition. 
Other changes were made to embellish the style, to delete erotic or gruesome elements, to eliminate tales that were too French.”
Artist Andrea Deszo’s new illustration for the tale The Devil in the Green Coat
Artist Andrea Deszo’s new illustration for the tale The Devil in the Green Coat
These included Bluebeard—the story of a man who keeps corpses of women in a locked room—and Puss in Boots.


In many cases certain tales of the first edition were replaced by longer and more elaborate versions.


Sometimes the Grimms change phrasing to make the stories more “proper”.



One example is Rapunzel, in which the young maiden in the tower becomes pregnant.



According to Jack the “essence of the tales is more vivid” in the earliest version where the Grimms made the “greatest effort to respect the voices of the original storytellers or collectors”.


The later morality doesn’t mean a lack of violence.


In Cinderella a girl overcomes impossible odds by virtue of her beauty and goodness.


The Grimms’ version in all their editions is the one where the spirit of the dead mother assists Cinderella, who visits the tree beneath which the mother is buried.


There are two sets of slippers, one silver, one gold.



Cinderella’s sisters, who have beautiful faces but black hearts, chop off their toes hoping to fit into the slipper, but the blood betrays them.



In the 1812 Grimm edition the story ends with Cinderella’s wedding. In the later edition there is an additional scene.


As the sisters approach the church, pigeons peck out their eyes. “And so they were punished for their wickedness and malice with blindness for the rest of their lives.”



It’s Snow White’s mother—not the step parent—who wanted to murder her daughter in the original tale.

“She was only seven years old,” said Jack.


“The mirror declares a seven year old more beautiful than this obviously beautiful queen, and the mother is so enraged that she wants her daughter murdered.



“In Hansel and Gretel, it’s also not a stepmother. It’s a biological mother who wants to abandon her daughter in the woods where they will probably be eaten by beasts.”



Partially this is sanitising, but it is also linked to how people lived at the time.



“Many women died during childbirth,” said Jack.



“The fathers would marry a very young woman who might be close in age to the eldest daughter and of course there would be a rivalry of some kind.”



That tension between the tales’ reflection of social reality and their ability to be retold continues today.

Jack pointed out, “Huge corporations such as the Disney Corporation view the tales as commodities.


“They are a means to make a huge profit in reinventing them because the tales are so popular. The exploitation of the Grimms’ tales occurs on many levels.



“The recent surge of fairy tale films reveals that Corporations will reproduce and exploit fairy tales to make profit and celebrate brand names of corporations.”



But despite the transformations, Jack argued that an underlying reason for the Grimms’ popularity remains.



“The tales engage readers and listeners because they present alternative worlds in which social justice occurs,” he said.



Cruel



“Sometimes the justice is retributive and cruel, but there is always a sense of social justice.”



Jack said this appeals at a time when justice seems lacking.



He said, “I believe we are living in perverse times, and that we, particularly in the US, have lost a sense of social justice.



“Our politicians and judges are total hypocrites and unjust in their actions, as are the billionaires who control our economy.



“We turn to and need fairy and folk tales not to escape but to maintain a sense of justice and hope that we can bring about more just societies.



“It is the legacy of social justice in the Grimms’ tales that keeps writers wanting to re-create them.



“Fortunately, creative and serious independent filmmakers and writers explore the tales because they might reveal how much inequality and injustice has grown, and how we might imagine alternatives to a deplorable reality.



“Fairy tales, including reinvented ones, seek to foster a sense of social justice.



“It is up to us as readers to realise the dreams and fantasies of these tales.”





READ MORE

The Original Folk and Fairy Tales of the Brothers Grimm: The Complete First Edition

by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm. Translated and edited by Jack Zipes and illustrated by Andrea Dezso (£16.97) 


Grimm Legacies: The Magic Spell of the Grimms’ Folk and Fairy Tales 
by Jack Zipes (£24.95) 

Fairy Tales and the Art of Subversion 
by Jack Zipes (£23.99) 

Available at Bookmarks, the socialist bookshop. Phone 020 7637 1848 or go to bookmarksbookshop.co.uk




This is C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot" for Tuesday: 


Tuesday, January 6, 2015.  Chaos and violence continue, DoD admits that there may have been civilian fatalities in those 'precision' air strikes, this may be used to argue for more US troops on the ground in Iraq, over 400 journalists have been killed in Iraq during the ongoing war, the ethnic cleansing continues in Iraq, and much more.



Starting with today's Defense Dept press briefing at the Pentagon moderated by spokesperson Rear Adm John Kirby.


Q: Admiral, when you said in response to Nancy's question with numbers, that hundreds of -- we know that hundreds of ISIL fighters have been killed, can you be more specific on that number? And also, can you give us any idea of civilians killed in the airstrike campaign?


KIRBY: I cannot give you a more specific number of -- of how many ISIL fighters. We just know it's hundreds: several hundred. It's not --

I'd like to make two points. First of all, we don't have the ability to -- to count every nose that we shwack [sic]. Number two, that's not the goal. That's not the goal. The less of these guys that are out there, certainly that's the better, but the goal is to degrade and destroy their capabilities.


And we're not getting into an issue of body counts. And that's why I don't have that number handy. I wouldn't -- I wouldn't have asked my staff to give me that number before I came out here. It's simply not a relevant figure.


On civilian casualties, what I know is that CENTCOM, Central Command, is investigating several, what they believe to be credible allegations of possible civilian casualties. I don't know all the details of that. I would point you to Central Command. I know that they are actively investigating what they believe to be at least a few incidents of civilian causalities that they think, you know, warrant further investigation, that they have found credible to investigate. On their own, they've done this. But again, I'd point you to Central Command for more detail on that.



And if I could just editorialize a second, I mean, this is something we always take seriously. We are very mindful of trying to mitigate the risk to civilians every time we operate, everywhere we operate. And so when we do believe that we've had occasion to cause collateral damage or hurt, kill civilians, we take it seriously and we look into it. It matters to us.



Of the above remarks, AFP points out, "The comments marked the first time the US military has acknowledged that the air war may have exacted a toll on civilians."  Kate Brannen (Foreign Policy) offers:

Depending on whether any civilian casualties are confirmed -- and where they may have happened -- these new investigations could move the debate around whether U.S. troops need to be moved closer to the battlefield, said Paul Scharre, a former Army Ranger.  He worked in the Office of the Secretary of Defense from 2008 to 2013 on intellligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance policies, among other issues, before joining the Center for a New American Security.
Some critics of the Obama administration’s strategy against the Islamic State have called for more air power, describing the current airstrikes as “pinpricks.” But to unleash more bombs on Iraq or Syria without inadvertently killing civilians would most likely require U.S. troops to move closer to the fight.



And that's the thing about selling war -- those who do can always use anything to sell even more of it.  "You say we're killing civilians?  Well the answer is for us to up our involvement!  Ground troops will save civilians!"

Sadly, there are many who will go along with that claim -- despite the fact that the years 2003 through 2011 in Iraq, with massive numbers of US troops on the ground -- did not create a safety zone for civilians.


The point Kirby raised about civilian deaths kind of got smoothed over in press reports.

Probably because this press lives to protect itself.

The issue isn't just that there may have been civilian deaths.

There was another important comment -- one that reflects on the press so they prefer to bury it.

Kirby noted, "First of all, we don't have the ability to -- to count every nose that we shwack [sic]."

The US government -- with all its military might, its Special Ops and CIA in Iraq, et al -- can't "count every nose that we whack."

Yet, day after day, the claims by the US government and/or the Iraqi government as to how many 'militants,' 'Da'ash,' 'terrorists,' what have you are treated as fact and repeated as such.

Not only can they not "count every nose," they can't guarantee that the dead were who they claim they were.

Instead of blindly repeating numbers and blindly calling them 'terrorists' or whatever, the press should be very dubious of the claims being made when a government -- any government -- reports 'kills.'  That lesson was supposed to have been learned during Vietnam when the US government regularly inflated the number of 'kills' to make it appear Vietnam was losing the war.

Let's stay with the press but move to the Iraqi press.  Sunday, Iraq's Journalistic Freedoms Observatory noted the year ended with 3 Iraqi journalists kidnapped in Mosul as elements of the Islamic State invaded their homes on December 31st and abducted them.   Meanwhile, Xinhua reports the Iraqi Journalists Syndicate announced today that 14 journalists were killed in Iraq in 2014 and at least 406 since the start of the war. Kitabat adds that the organization noted the "major role" that the press serves in forming public opinion.


Staying with the media, the Washington Post's Erin Cunningham offers some media criticism:



  • Going back to the topic of violence, Alsumaria reports 4 corpses were discovered dumped in Baghdad (all shot to death). Mohammed Tawfeeq, Jason Hanna, Laura Smith-Spark and Jethro Mullen (CNN) add, "ISIS militants attacked the Albu Risha police station in northern Ramadi, killing several police officers and injuring at least two other people, the security officials said."  AFP reports, "The suicide bombers attacked a mosque in the Al-Jubba area of Anbar where anti-militant fighters were resting, killing 10, after which clashes broke out that left a further 13 security personnel dead and 21 wounded." Margaret Griffis (Antiwar.com) counts 132 people killed in violence throughout Iraq today with another thirty left injured.


    The violence in Iraq has frequently taken the form of ethnic cleansing.  Reider Visser denies this reality from the comfort of his padded cell and he's supported by the likes of Jane Arraf, Joel Wing and other of Nouri al-Maliki's bow-down-bitches but the facts support ethnic cleansing in the past and currently.


    Hamza Hendawi and Qassim Abdul-Zahra (AP) report on the Sunni town of Rawashid where Shi'ite forces pushed out the Islamic State and their leader, Adnan Hassan, states Sunnis will never be allowed to return to their homes, "These are our lands."


    And the bow-down-bitches?

    Silence from them.  Though one of them, Jane, does make a point to Tweet fairy tales.


    A bow-down-bitch can always trumpet fiction that ignores the continued targeting of Sunnis because a bow-down-bitch always ignores the targeting of Sunnis.  Jane Arraf's certainly made that her goal for years now.
    Tuesday was the 94th anniversary of the founding of the Iraqi army. Though Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi has participated in various photo-ops, not all feel it's a day worth celebrating.  Communities long victimized by the Iraqi military, such as the Kurds, are not feeling joyful.  It's doubtful that the Shi'ites would be if they weren't now in charge of the killing machine.

    You may remember the White House has been (weakly) pushing a national guard -- one made up of various demographic components in Iraq.  Pushing that since the summer.

    Yesterday, National Iraqi News Agency reported MP Amin Bakr (with the Kurdish Change or Goran bloc) declared he expected the bill to come before the Parliament this month.  However, the Cabinet of Ministers has still yet to vote on it.  You may remember all the promises about a vote in Parliament on the budget being just around the corner.

    Despite hearing that for months, it's still not happened.  And it may not for months.  The budget is now tied to the oil and gas deal between Baghdad and Erbil.  Iraq never got around to passing a 2014 budget and, as 2015 begins, a budget for this year seems doubtful as well.


    Saif Hameed, Ned Parker and Dominic Evans (Reuters) report on the issues with the Iraqi military (which include the issue of corruption which plagues all of Iraq).  Al Mada notes that Prime Minister al-Abadi pledged today to end corruption in the military.


    And that really underscores how the White House is yet again failing in Iraq.

    Oil is dropping.

    The previous drop meant Iraq's proposed budget slashed pretty much everything but defense.

    The Iraqi government wants military weapons, they want military training and the US is supplying it.
    The Washington Post's Rajiv Chandrasekaran Tweets:

  • U.S. Selling 170 More M-1 Abrams Tanks to Iraq After the Iraqi Army Lost 40 Last Summer to ISIS

  • And AFP Tweets:




  • And this is done for what?
    The White House is getting what for these gifts?
    Nothing.

    Where are the demands that Iraq needs to do X to get Y?

    Where's the diplomatic effort?
    They could have stated nothing happened until the national guard bill became law, for example.

    They could have used the Iraqi government's desires as levers to press for needed reforms.


    They didn't.


    And instead of calling out this diplomatic failure, where are we on the left?

    As Mike pointed out, Ray McGovern (retired CIA) notes the State Dept . . . in terms of John Kerry.  In the conspiracy-crazed mind of bow-down-bitch Ray McGovern, the Secretary of State is controlling the President of the United States Barack Obama.

    It's when they get that nutty that bow-down-bitches should just bow out.

    Although we should also question the glorification of CIA Ray McGovern to begin with.

    This is the man who defended the dirty tricks of the US government in Vietnam -- defended it on Pacifica Radio -- and not in ancient times but during the reign of his blessed Barack.  Years, decades, after the bulk of the world -- and the left in the US -- disowns the travesty and crimes of US counterinsurgency efforts  in Vietnam, bow-down-bitch Ray McGovern takes to Pacifica to shine those efforts on.

    The left needs to learn that when you lay down with the likes of Ray McGovern, gonorrhea may be the least of the problems you awake with.

    And it's a mystery why anyone would listen to -- or, heaven forbid, follow -- a bow-down-bitch who, six year into War Hawk Barack's presidency, still makes excuses and peddles fantasies to avoid holding Barack accountable.

    Reminder if you missed them last week, 2014 year-in-review pieces:  Isaiah's "2014 Self-Exposure," Kat's "Kat's Korner: 2014 In Music," Ruth's "Ruth's Radio Report 2014," Martha and Shirley's "2014 in Books (Martha & Shirley)"  Ann and Stan's "2014 in Film (Ann and Stan)" which first went up at their own sites as Ann's "2014 in Films (Ann and Stan)" and Stan's "2014 in film (Ann and Stan)," Third's "2014 Notable Events," Trina's "Detroit" and my "2014: The Year of Self-Exposure."


    This morning, I forgot to include the community updates (and we'll know Jody Watley as well):


















  • cnn



    Tuesday, January 06, 2015

    Brief


    Read this at WSWS on the post office.  It's important.

    So is sleep and I'm so tired.  SO that's it for me.


    This is C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot" for Monday:  


    Monday, January 5, 2014.  Chaos and violence continue, Kevin Drum tries to rewrite the Iraq War, the State Dept loves it when other countries offer advancement for women (even if the White House won't), and much more.



    Let's start with the garbage, Kevin Drum.

    The trash that Mother Jones continues to employ wants to pin the blame for the Iraq War starting on Fox News.  (Through click bait -- Limpy never can deliver, he goes flaccid way too quickly.)

    In his puzzling piece of nonsense, never are the words "I watched Fox News" written.

    Because, let's remember, Kevin Drum was a whore for war, he championed it.

    And FAIR can whine all it wants about how the media refuses to shut those types out of the conversation today but until they call out Mother Jones for employing human garbage like Kevin Drum, FAIR's a damn hypocrite.

    So what's the little bitch doing today?

    Oh, he's pretending Fox News is responsible for starting the illegal war.

    That lie let's a lot of people off the hook including himself.

    But the reality -- always too hard for Kevin Drum to get honest about -- is that NBC's Meet The Press sold the illegal war, Oprah Winfrey sold the illegal war on her daytime talk show, Judith Miller, Michael Gordon and others at the New York Times sold the illegal war, reporters for the Washington Post and the Los Angeles Times sold the illegal war, NBC Nightly News sold the illegal war, ABC's Good Morning America sold the illegal war, Dan Rather sold the illegal war . . .

    On and on, it went.

    I'm really getting sick of these whores who want to pin it on Fox News.

    They want to hope people forgot or never knew what went down.

    The Kevin Drums and Juan Coles and all the other pieces of human filth that sold the illegal war now want to pretend otherwise.

    I'm no fan of Fox News but I won't take part in the lie that it was Fox News that sold the illegal war.

    Fox News couldn't have done it on its own.

    It took 'respectable' whores like Kevin Drum and Juan Cole and so many others.

    Kevin can lie all he wants but until the day he dies he will be haunted by the Iraqis killed in the illegal war he pimped to America.

    Let's move over to the brief mention of Iraq that took place in today's US State Dept press briefing moderated by spokesperson Jen Psaki.


    QUESTION: The Kurdish officials are engaged in an effort to gain international recognition for the massacre of the Yezidis by ISIS as genocide. Do you – I mean, I know President Obama used the word genocide in his --


    MS. PSAKI: Mm-hmm.



    QUESTION: -- first address to authorize military action on Mount Sinjar. Does the United States believe that what ISIS ended up doing on that mountain or in Sinjar town, in general*, constitute genocide?



    MS. PSAKI: Well, I would point you to what the President has already said. I don’t have any new definitions for you.



    QUESTION: Is it --



    MS. PSAKI: Obviously, what happened there was horrific. It was barbaric. We took very quick action to help address the situation. I’m not going to put new labels on it today.



    QUESTION: But wouldn’t recognizing the slaughter as genocide, like, boost U.S. efforts to degrade and defeat ISIS, like in this --



    MS. PSAKI: I think the actions we took at the time, including military action, coordinating the world’s significant humanitarian action, spoke to our concerns and how strongly we felt about it.



    QUESTION: Just one more question, Jen.



    MS. PSAKI: Mm-hmm.



    QUESTION: The KRG also appointed Bayan Sami Abdul Rahman, a woman from Sinjar, actually, as its representative in Washington. She arrived here yesterday. What do you – do you have anything to say on that decision by the KRG – a woman from Sinjar to be in Washington?



    MS. PSAKI: Well, we certainly support women in prominent positions as a government. I don’t think I have more specifics. Are you asking of their – do you have another specific question?



    QUESTION: Do you welcome the decision?




    MS. PSAKI: I don’t have any more details for you.



    Do "we certainly support women in prominent positions as a government"?

    First off, it's not even functional, the statement.  But let's pretend Psaki wasn't speaking like a robot.

    Does the US support women in prominent positions of government?


    You'd never know it to look at the US ambassador to Iraq.

    1) Chris Hill

    2) James Jeffrey

    3) Brett McGurk

    4) Robert S. Beecroft

    5) Stuart E. Jones


    Those are the five men Barack's nominated for the post.

    There are no five women he's nominated.

    All but Brett McGurk were confirmed by the Senate.

    Since Brett couldn't be confirmed, Barack just -- slap in the face to the Senate -- put him in charge of Iraq.

    Five nominees, five chances and he gave him all to men.

    This isn't about 'oh the women who weren't given a chance!'

    That's a serious issue but that's not the issue we're raising now -- or have been raising forever (including to Barack's transition team following the 2008 election prior to Barack being sworn in as president)..

    Iraqi women have suffered in the Iraq War.  They've suffered from a US government that didn't just an order an invasion into their country but a US government who put thugs in charge and then looked the other way as these same thugs repeatedly attempted to strip women of their legal rights.

    It was Iraqi women, not the US government, who fought these attempts.  It was Iraqi women who took to the streets in protest.

    Iraq is a young country.  The CIA puts the median age at 21.5 years.

    The Iraq War hits the 12 year mark this March.

    The population that can remember when women had equal rights continues to decrease.

    Barack, a symbolic president -- after six years, that's the only credit on his resume, should have grasped the importance of symbolism.  A woman in the position would have been a symbolic asset for the Iraqi people.

    As for Bayan Sami Abdul Rahman, she was actually promoted to this current position back in October.  Today was her first day on the job.




    In January of 2013, she attended the International Conference entitled The Untold Story: The Kurdish Genocide in Iraq and noted:

    This year sees a convergence of significant anniversaries of events that have had an immense impact on the people of Kurdistan in Iraq. It is not only the 25th anniversary of the poison gas attack on Halabja and the Anfal genocide campaign, it is also the 30th anniversary of the abduction and killing of men and boys from the Barzani tribe and the 10th anniversary of the West's intervention in Iraq, which we Kurds refer to as the liberation. January 17, the day this conference is being held, marks the 22nd year since Operation Desert Storm which triggered a sequence of events that eventually led to the Kurdish Uprising of 1991 and Kurdistan’s first breath of freedom. 
    Apart from noting this unusual coming together of memorable dates, we see this as an opportunity to reveal the horrific crimes that the Kurdish people have fallen victim to since the 1960s, to tell the secret story of life under Saddam Hussein's brutal dictatorship, to give the victims and survivors a voice and to have a debate on the issues that surround genocide. How is genocide legally defined ? What are the challenges to legal and political international recognition? What role did the Kurdish diaspora play in raising awareness of the atrocities in their homeland at the time and what is their role today? What can we do to prevent other genocides? How can we ensure that those who helped the perpetrators or profited from those crimes are brought to justice? What lessons can be learnt from experts, NGOs and survivors of other genocides such as in Rwanda and Bosnia ? 
    It is with these questions in mind that we decided to host the first international conference in Britain on the Kurdish genocide. As we look around the Middle East, we see much to be concerned about, including the situation in Syria. The slaughter of people, including children, while the international community vacillates as to how to respond, brings back memories of those events in Iraqi Kurdistan not so long ago. Of course it is not easy to intervene in another country's strife but surely the international community has a responsibility to protect people who have no defence against a well armed dictatorship that does not hesitate to use violence to suppress dissent. 
    Since we announced this conference, three Kurdish women activists were assassinated in Paris. They strived for Kurdish rights and their murder reminds us that even today, in the heart of Western Europe, Kurds are not safe. Sadly, our history is interspersed with assassinated leaders and activists, yet few Kurds think to give up the struggle for Kurdish rights or to evade the duty to remember and honour those who have been killed.
    The subject of this conference show s the dark side of humanity. Yet time and again, listening to the survivors and eyewitnesses to the horrors of poison gas, imprisonment, torture and mass murder, we hear of small gestures of kindness that lifted the spirit of someone who was in utter despair, we hear of the risks people took to save a stranger's life as in the case of the Shia Arab family that rescued Teimour , a young Kurdish boy who had escaped from a pit full of dead bodies. We also see the survivors' desire to forge a better future for their children and to spread the word of peace. We hope that this conference will not only make us listen and search for answers, but also gain inspiration.


    That'll give you an overview of the issues that matter to her.  When she was named the KRG's High Representative to the UK, the Kurdish Regional Government noted:


    Before her appointment, Ms Abdul Rahman worked as a journalist for 17 years. She began her career on local newspapers in London and won the Observer Newspaper’s Farzad Bazoft Memorial Prize in 1993, which led her to work at The Observer and later at the Financial Times. She worked for the FT in Britain and in Japan, where she was Tokyo Correspondent.
    Her late father, Sami Abdul Rahman, was a veteran of the Kurdish movement, joining the Kurdistan Democratic Party in 1963 and playing a critical role in the Kurdish and Iraqi opposition to Saddam Hussein’s regime. He held the post of Deputy Prime Minister of the Kurdistan Regional Government and General Secretary of the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP). Sami Abdul Rahman was killed alongside his elder son Salah and 96 others in a twin suicide bombing in 2004. 



    While she's been successful in her positions other officials haven't fared so well.

    Take thug Nouri al-Maliki.  The man Bully Boy Bush imposed on Iraq, demanded he be prime minister is, was and always will be a thug.  Despite that reality, in 2010, when Nouri lost to Ayad Allawi, Barack Obama demanded Nouri get a second term.

    That second term pulled Iraq ever closer to the abyss as Nouri attacked protesters, allowed his goons to rape girls and women in Iraqi jails and prisons, bullied politicians, threatened leaders of neighboring countries and much more.


    Nouri's finally out as prime minister (Haider al-Abadi currently holds the title) but Nouri has reportedly told his flunkies that he'll be back in the post of prime minister in a matter of months.  Currently, he spews his crazy from the post of Vice President -- he's one of three -- the other two are Osama al-Nujaifi and, yes, Ayad Allawi.



    Former European Union member Struan Stevenson offers:


     Riven with dishonesty and fraud, the Iraqi army mirrors the rampant corruption of the Iraqi government in post-Saddam Iraq.
    These circumstances have provided the perfect conditions for the brutal Shiite militias to thrive and take control of the battlefield. There are perhaps hundreds of these militias. They are trained, financed and often led by the terrorist Iranian Quds Force. They are Iranian proxies. So the US air strikes are aiding and abetting Iran in achieving its ultimate objective, which is total control of Iraq.
    The current war raging across Iraq was as avoidable as it was predictable. Nouri al-Maliki’s second term as prime minister was a tragedy for the Iraqi people, for the region and for the world. As a puppet of the Iranian mullahs, he encouraged the Iranian-led Shiite militias and used them to enforce his merciless “iron fist” sectarian policy of indiscriminate bombing, shelling, arbitrary arrests, torture and mass execution of innocent Sunni civilians. Maliki utilised the claim of fighting a war against terror to secure his grip on power and the West fell for it. 



    Nouri's failures and crimes are well known.  Despite that reality, Nouri attempted to rewrite history on Sunday.   AFP reports:


    Iraqi Vice President Nouri al-Maliki, who was widely criticized for sectarian policies during his time as premier, said Sunday that politicians are to blame for the country’s Sunni-Shiite strife.
    “There is no problem between the Sunnis and the Shiites as communities, but rather between us the politicians -- we think as Sunnis and Shiites, and we are driving people toward this doom, for which we will bear responsibility before God,” he said.
    Maliki himself pursued policies that marginalized and angered members of Iraq’s Sunni Arab minority, especially during his second term as premier.



    Richard Engel is a correspondent for NBC News.  Today, he Tweeted.




  • As of now there are 2,140 American soldiers and Marines in Iraq, to grow to around 3k this spring.



  • Staying with the topic of US service members in Iraq, Nikki Henderson (Nexstar Broadcasting) reports that US Col Steve Warren has confirmed that US troops stationed at al-Assad airbase are under regular mortar assault from the Islamic State with Warren terming the assaults "completely ineffective."  (So far, at any rate.) Barbara Starr (CNN) adds the attacks are "raising continuing concern that U.S. forces in Iraq can be kept safe and at least technically out of a combat role, a separate defense official said. The Pentagon would not say whether security measures had changed at the base."






    Earlier today, Abdulrahman al-Rashed noted new efforts at diplomacy between Iraq and Saudi Arabi and wondered, "Will a Saudi embassy in Baghdad end tensions with Iraq?"

    Later, BBC News notes, there was a suicide bomber attacking the border Iraq and Saudi Arabia share.  Angus McDowall (Reuters) counts 3 of the Saudi border employees dead.  Alsumaria notes Iraq's Ministry of Foreign Affairs denounced the attack.

    In other violence, Sputnik notes, "Iraq's security forces have killed at least 26 Islamic State (IS) militants in the country's northern province of Salah al-Din, a military source told the Iraqi News agency on Monday."
    Margaret Griffis (Antiwar.com) counts 52 dead across Iraq from violence today.



















    Saturday, January 03, 2015

    So i figured I'd stream a Lindsay Wagner TV movie . . .

    Lindsay Wagner is a strong actress who's been good in films (The Paper Chase) and TV (The Bionic Woman -- for which she won an Emmy).  In the last decades, she's mainly worked in TV movies and has a long string of classic ones.

    So I'm at Hulu and see a Lifetime movie starring Lindsay Wagner called Fighting For My Daughter.

    Her character's daughter gets caught up in prostitution.

    If you know anything about Lifetime, you know that plot's been used in many Lifetime films.

    So Hulu says it's a 2003 film and I don't remember anything that recent so I start streaming.

    The first scene, Lindsay and her daughter are in the car, music blasting.  And then the daughter changes the music . . . by ejecting a cassette tape and replacing it with another that she brags is new and she just got.

    2003?

    No.

    It's a 1995 television movie.

    Lindsay great.  Piper Laurie is as well.  The whole cast.  Including Paul Lieber  and Chad Lowe.

    But I wish Hulu could get the basics right. 

    I just feel like there are enough lies in the world, get your facts right.

    I don't get how it's difficult for Hulu to get the year right of the films they're showing.

    It's sloppy at best.


    Now let me note the year-in-review coverage:


     2014 year-in-review pieces:  Isaiah's "2014 Self-Exposure," Kat's "Kat's Korner: 2014 In Music," Ruth's "Ruth's Radio Report 2014," Martha and Shirley's "2014 in Books (Martha & Shirley)"  Ann and Stan's "2014 in Film (Ann and Stan)" which first went up at their own sites as Ann's "2014 in Films (Ann and Stan)" and Stan's "2014 in film (Ann and Stan)," Third's "2014 Notable Events" and my "2014: The Year of Self-Exposure."


    A few of you e-mailed, "C.I. ignored you!!!"  No, she didn't.  I asked her not to include my Detroit post.  The idea behind it was good but I think I wrote very poorly. 

    She said, "Okay, I'll leave it out this week."

    And I note she hasn't included them in the snapshot today.

    Which means she will note in the snapshot.

    So I need to get her to promise that, come Monday's snapshot, I'm not included.


    This is C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot" for Saturday:  


    Saturday, January 3, 2015.  Chaos and violence continue, 3 Sunni clerics are assassinated and the White House is silent, 3 Sunni children are part of 20 civilians killed in Falluja and the White House is silent, Barack wants US troops to train the League of Righteous and America is silent, and much more.

    Nickolay Mladenov has declared, "The Iraqi ordinary citizen continues to suffer from violence and terrorism.  2014 has seen the highest number of causalities since the violence in 2006 - 2007."

    Nickolay Mladenov is United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon's special envoy to Iraq.  The United Nations Assistance Mission for Iraq counts at least 12,282 deaths and 23,126 people left injured.  This doesn't include Anbar which means the numbers are significantly higher since Anbar is the scene of much violence.

    Not including Anbar not only reduces the number of dead and wounded, it also allows people to pose and pretend.

    'Oh, that awful Islamic State! Killing innocent civilians!'

    You mean like the Iraqi government does?

    Alsumaria reports 20 civilians were killed in Falluja yesterday -- including 3 children -- and another twenty left injured.

    Who killed and wounded those people?

    The Iraqi military.

    They've been bombing residential neighborhoods in Falluja since January.  It's a War Crime.

    Nickolay Mladenov has made one statement opposing it -- it's now a year that it's been going on, that the Iraqi government has been killing Iraqi civilians.

    And Nickolay thinks one statement takes care of it?

    Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon has never said one word.

    Not one word.

    Does he really think he represent the best of the world's aspirations by staying silent about a government killing civilians?

    1900.

    That's not the century.

    That's the number of civilian corpses Falluja General Hospital has received since the fall of victims of these attacks.

    1900 is the number the western press won't tell you.

    1900 is the number of innocents whose lives didn't matter to the Iraqi government and whose deaths clearly do not matter to the world press, to the White House or to the United Nations.

    At what point does the world insist that the Iraqi government stop killing Iraqi civilians?

    If you're wondering that's why the UN doesn't include Anbar in their death tolls -- they don't want to confront the reality that people are being killed -- so many are being killed -- by the Iraqi government.


    It's not because they can't 'verify' the deaths.  They can verify deaths in Anbar as easily as they can anywhere else in Iraq -- in fact, they can verify them in Anbar a great deal easier than they can in Nineveh Province (especially Mosul).

    They chose not to include Anbar and have done so because they don't want to 'embarrass' the Iraqi government.

    Never forget that: The UN which proclaims "it's your world" bends over backwards to avoid documenting the deaths in Anbar because they don't want to 'embarrass' the Iraqi government.



    And the White House just doesn't give a damn about Sunnis.

    Doubt it?

    Qassim Abdul-Zahra (AP) reported Friday about an attack in Basra Thursday night which left 3 Sunni clerics dead.  The State Dept said nothing.

    No statement was issued.

    Nothing.

    Not even a damn tweet.

    Three religious leaders are assassinated and two more are injured and the White House is silent -- Joe Biden's Twitter feed had time yesterday for Brazil, the State Dept had time for North Korea, the State Dept's Brett McGurk had time to trumpet bombings and other non-State Dept issues -- everyone's silent.


    They'll issue a statement on the Shi'ites at the drop of hat.

    But the Sunni community -- and it's noticed in Iraq -- can be attacked, can be savaged and the from the White House on down, the administration just doesn't give a damn.

    And that's clear by the White House's refusal to call out the bombing of residential neighborhoods in Iraq.  These are legally defined War Crimes -- recognized as such by the US government.  And it is incumbent upon the White House to call them out.

    These War Crimes?  They also legally mean the White House cannot arm the Iraqi government -- not when it's killing Iraqi civilians.  And this isn't in doubt, it's been going on since January of 2014.  It is documented, it is established.

    Again, the White House silence is noted by Sunnis in Iraq.

    Of the assassination,  AFP notes that "the Iraqi Islamic Party, one of the main Sunni political parties, said the attack was carried out by 'criminal militias,' an apparent reference to Shiite fighters Baghdad has turned to for support in its battle against IS."  And, of course, these Shi'ite militias forces would have been part of Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi's tour of Basra on December 31st and clearly could have stayed the next day to take part in the assassinations.  The Iraqi military that the US wants to train first needs to be purged of all criminal militia elements -- including those who, of course, kidnapped and killed US troops -- for those who missed it, Barack Obama released some of those in 2009 as a deal to get the League of Righteous to release the 1 living British hostage and the corpses of the other British hostages -- but remember, Barack insists that he doesn't make deals with terrorists.  The League of Righteous has been very clear that a deal was made -- very clear to the Iraqi press.

    We're going to do a lengthy sidebar right now on the League, National Iraqi News Agency reports the League's Qais al-Khazail declared Tuesday that the United States and Israel were conspiring to destroy Iraq.

    And that's who Barack's sending US troops to train.

    The League is also known as Assaib al-Haq.  Tim Arango (New York Times) reported in September of 2013 that thug Nouri al-Malliki, then the prime minister of Iraq, had brought the Shi'ite militias under his wing -- providing them with military uniforms and weapons:




    In supporting Asaib al-Haq, Mr. Maliki has apparently made the risky calculation that by backing some Shiite militias, even in secret, he can maintain control over the country’s restive Shiite population and, ultimately, retain power after the next national elections, which are scheduled for next year. Militiamen and residents of Shiite areas say members of Asaib al-Haq are given government badges and weapons and allowed freedom of movement by the security forces.


    Again, this is the military that Barack wants US troops to train.  Grasp that.

    If you're not getting how disgusting this is, let's drop back to the June 9th snapshot:

    This morning the New York Times' Alissa J. Rubin and Michael Gordon offered "U.S. Frees Suspect in Killing of 5 G.I.'s." Martin Chulov (Guardian) covered the same story, Kim Gamel (AP) reported on it, BBC offered "Kidnap hope after Shia's handover" and Deborah Haynes contributed "Hope for British hostages in Iraq after release of Shia militant" (Times of London). The basics of the story are this. 5 British citizens have been hostages since May 29, 2007. The US military had in their custody Laith al-Khazali. He is a member of Asa'ib al-Haq. He is also accused of murdering five US troops. The US military released him and allegedly did so because his organization was not going to release any of the five British hostages until he was released. This is a big story and the US military is attempting to state this is just diplomacy, has nothing to do with the British hostages and, besides, they just released him to Iraq. Sami al-askari told the New York Times, "This is a very sensitive topic because you know the position that the Iraqi government, the U.S. and British governments, and all the governments do not accept the idea of exchanging hostages for prisoners. So we put it in another format, and we told them that if they want to participate in the political process they cannot do so while they are holding hostages. And we mentioned to the American side that they cannot join the political process and release their hostages while their leaders are behind bars or imprisoned." In other words, a prisoner was traded for hostages and they attempted to not only make the trade but to lie to people about it. At the US State Dept, the tired and bored reporters were unable to even broach the subject. Poor declawed tabbies. Pentagon reporters did press the issue and got the standard line from the department's spokesperson, Bryan Whitman, that the US handed the prisoner to Iraq, the US didn't hand him over to any organization -- terrorist or otherwise. What Iraq did, Whitman wanted the press to know, was what Iraq did. A complete lie that really insults the intelligence of the American people. CNN reminds the five US soldiers killed "were: Capt. Brian S. Freeman, 31, of Temecula, California; 1st Lt. Jacob N. Fritz, 25, of Verdon, Nebraska; Spc. Johnathan B. Chism, 22, of Gonzales, Louisiana; Pfc. Shawn P. Falter, 25, of Cortland, New York; and Pfc. Johnathon M. Millican, 20, of Trafford, Alabama." Those are the five from January 2007 that al-Khazali and his brother Qais al-Khazali are supposed to be responsible for the deaths of. Qassim Abdul-Zahra and Robert H. Reid (AP) states that Jonathan B. Chism's father Danny Chism is outraged over the release and has declared, "They freed them? The American military did? Somebody needs to answer for it."

    No one ever did.  Barack was never held accountable for it.

    But grasp that US troops are being expected to advise and train those who targeted and killed them but those who are running around Iraq telling the press that the US is conspiring with Israel to destroy Iraq.



    Let's go back to the assassination of the 3 clerics.  Alsumaria notes that Speaker of Parliament Salim al-Jubouri has called Friday for a serious investigation, for accountability and for prosecution over these assassinations (two more clerics were left injured in the attack).  And, no surprise, he's not satisfied with leaving the investigation to the Ministry of the Interior and wants Parliament to form an investigative committee as well.


    For Friday's violence, Alsumaria notes an Abu Ghraib roadside bombing has left 1 person dead and four more injured, a Hussein roadside bombing has left seven people injured, and a Mahmudiya sticky bombing left two people injured. All Iraq News notes that the corpses of 3 police members were discovered dumped in Tikrit,  AFP reports that the Islamic State kidnapped "a total of 170 men were taken from the villages of Al-Shajara and Gharib in Kirkuk province, after two ISIS flags were burned in the area, an account confirmed by other officials from the province."




    With the Iraqi military failing in Mosul so spectacularly last year, Parliament is investigating what went wrong. National Iraqi News Agency notes that Moqtada al-Sadr's bloc has stated they are prepared to call Nouri al-Maliki to testify in Parliament if the investigation warrants it.  Nouri is now one of Iraq's three vice presidents.  At the time of the fall of Mosul, he was the prime minister of Iraq.  More recently, Nouri attempted to publicly pin the blame for his failures as commander-in-chief with the fall of Mosul on the Kurds.













    Thursday, January 01, 2015

    Detroit

    For me, the story of 2014 was the media silence around what took place in Detroit.

    To be clear, the fleecing of Detroit continues.

    But for me the big story was how little the media cared.

    If you leave out the work of WSWS and Black Agenda Report, the reality is that the media didn't care at all.

    WSWS and BAR led on the coverage.

    And they continued to cover the scandal even when no one else wanted to help them.




    This is C.I.'s "Iraq snapshot" for Wednesday:


    Wednesday, December 31, 2014.  As Iraq is gripped by violence, we look at the whoring and the lying that allowed it to happen.


    If you ever questioned the proposition that US politicians are basically crooked and dishonest, let's note two people writing about Iraq today.


    Jack A. Smith (Dissident Voice) offers:


    The U.S. war against Iraq ended officially December 31, 2011, but it has now metamorphosed into Washington’s air war against the Islamic State (IS) in Iraq and Syria. There are increasing hints U.S. ground troops may be sent in this year. (3,000 American military advisers are already there and 1,500 allied troops are expected soon.)


    We can all follow that.


    And now here's nutty Dennis Kucinich, former US House Rep:

    Establish a US Commission on Truth and Reconciliation. America was led into a war against Iraq, a war which killed over 1 million innocent Iraqis, a war which was based on every manner of deceit. In our name, and with our tax dollars, countless people were either killed, injured or tortured, their homes ruined, the land destroyed. It is time for Americans to know the truth about Iraq and other wars. Let us push Congress and the President to create a US Commission on Truth and Reconciliation.
    We must require the highest level of accountability from those who have held the highest positions in our government. Lies which took us into war and established a national security state have separated us from each other, and from the world. Let us reunite in the spirit of truth and justice, seeking the moral high ground and a newer world.



    Can Dennis just stop f**king around and lying.

    There will not be -- in the next 20 years at least -- a US Commission on Truth and Reconciliation.  Why are you wasting people's time deceiving them?

    There are things to focus on and your nonsense is not one of them.

    You want a Truth Commission?  How about you tell the American people about the flight you took with Barack?  How about you explain how you got on that plane insisting you were sticking to your guns and not voting for ObamaCare but by the time you touched ground you were breaking your public promise?  Why don't you tell the American people about that conversation?

    It would be illuminating.

    Not just to show the world self-serving you are, but to explain how politics in the US really work.

    Dennis is a disgrace.  I've always felt that way.

    Now he's writing of Iraq as if the illegal war is over.  That's offensive enough.

    But he's lying to the American people as well.  A decision was made to go war on Iraq.  That wasn't -- though Dennis loves to pretend otherwise -- a decision of just Republicans or of just Republicans plus Hillary Clinton.

    It's not going to happen.

    And this gets to the core of why I despise Dennis.

    In 2004, in Boston, as he let down his supporters -- which really is the constant thread in the public career of Dennis Kucinich -- a young woman approached me crying, feeling he betrayed her and the rest and I comforted by leading her (eventually) in a chant of "F**k Dennis Kucinich!"

    Dennis is never serious, Dennis is a con artist.

    His runs in the Democrat parties presidential primaries -- which, let's be clear, is not running for president, he's never run for president -- are fake.

    They're an attempt to corral people into the Democratic Party (and keep them from going to the Green Party or elsewhere).  After his fake run,  Dennis gives his little fake ass speech, after denouncing the party, urging his supporters to support the Democratic Party.  He's a tiny valve intended to release steam and frustration before all of us on the left are supposed to join hands and march behind whomever the party's decided gets the nomination.

    In 2008, Barack Obama 'won' Iowa.

    After the early round of the caucus, Dennis instructed his followers to take their support to Barack.

    At what point does that little bitch plan to take accountability for that?

    I believe Barack's actions in Libya were illegal.  I called them out here.

    Dennis did so on Fox News.  But never took accountability for his role in promoting Barack Obama and helping to make him the nominee for the Democratic Party.

    Dennis has never, ever run for president.

    Don't believe the lies of Amy Goodman.

    He's participated -- poorly -- in the Democratic Party's primaries.

    Cynthia McKinney ran for president, Ralph Nader ran for president, H. Ross Perot ran for president, Barack ran for president, John McCain ran, etc.

    But Dennis never ran for president.

    The most he ever ran for was the Democratic Party's presidential nomination.

    There's a huge difference between that and running for president.

    Look at any of his speeches when he repeatedly sought the party's nomination in one cycle after another.

    Read the speeches and ask yourself, "If someone really believes that, why don't they run for president?"

    Dennis is a fake ass.

    He lives to distract.  Maybe because he's so nutty.  Maybe because that's the role he's assigned himself.

    But he's worthless time and again.

    If he wants to matter, it's not that hard.  Tell the truth about the plane ride.  Explain to Americans how you changed your mind on that plane ride.

    He doesn't want to talk about the truth.

    Talking about the truth might change the system.  It would certainly upset the apple cart.  So instead, he keeps lying and distracting.

    At a certain point, his freak show doesn't even deliver snorts of derision.

    At that point, he becomes an embarrassment that the world simply can't afford.

    Dennis could have ended the Iraq War at any point.  Any member of the US Congress could have.  Former US Senator Mike Gravel told those truths and the response was John Edwards and Hillary Clinton caught on mike talking about how to purge certain people from the debates.


    Real quick, let's see if we're all idiots like Dennis.  Here's the test. Can you  read Ahmed Rasheed and Ned Parker's latest report for Reuters and grasp what they're saying:


    As Shi'ite forces push into territories held by Islamic State, many Sunnis have fled for fear of both the Shi’ite-led government and the Sunni jihadists.
    Shi'ite leaders insist Islamic State must never be allowed to strike them again, nor return to areas now abandoned.
    Shi'ite groups now decide who can stay in a community and who should leave; whose houses should be destroyed and whose can stand.
    In one case, a powerful Shi’ite paramilitary organization has started redrawing the geography of central Iraq, building a road between Shi’ite parts of Diyala province and Samarra, a Sunni city that is home to a Shi’ite shrine.


    You can summarize the above as Shi'ites clear out an area of the Islamic State and then purge the Sunni elements as well.

    So you're not a complete idiot or crazy.

    Not everyone can make that claim.

    This morning, we noted the article and ethnic cleansing in Iraq.

    Crazy Reider Visser  takes to Twitter with his own brand of insanity.

    Maybe he thinks he's successfully disputing Ned Parker and Ahmed Rasheed?


    As we explained "A crackpot runs AFP, Al Jazeera and the Christian Science Monitor" (June, 2013), this is the 'expert' who was running around the globe insisting the CIA was pretending to be the State Dept and he was being persecuted and hunted and his parents wanted him to get mental help.  As we explained:


    The man's a loon.  Read his September 2012 post for laughs.  He's being 'punished' and 'stalked' by the police in his country because . . . he took photos.  He didn't understand it was a crime, he writes, before making a xenophobic remark about the Japanese.  But Reider was done with his country.  He moved to England.  But the Norwegian police followed him there as well!  And continued to harass him.  So he went to the US and, "The Norwegians came after me to the United States as well. Easily recognisable officers of the organised crime unit within the Oslo police even followed me into research libraries where they deliberately sat next to me and made noise in order to disturb my work on Iraq."
    Yeah, watch out, in US libraries, for those Norwegian police crime units.




    It needs to be noted, and it has been repeatedly here, Reider and Joel Wing and all the little Circle Jerk buddies?

    They weren't telling truths.

    They were lying.

    They were pimping for Nouri al-Maliki -- a thug. They were passing him off as a leader.

    He led Iraq, alright, into the brink of destruction.

    For all those just so amazed at the violence today in Iraq, so surprised by it, let's drop back for more of the June 2013 entry where we noted crazy Reider:




    AFP's gotta be the dumbest and trashiest in the secretarial pool as evidenced by their latest nonsense. Nouri's gone on state TV (which he controls) to say what's happening in Syria is causing sectarian strife in Iraq.  Who knew AFP was also Iraqi state TV?

    It must be because all it can do is present his comments in a vacuum, as if to exonerate his own actions and convict the Iraqis.

    The most obvious point to make re: Syria is that, if true (it's not), how interesting that Nouri chose not to side with the west on the issue.

    What goes on in Syria is not why there is sectarian strife in Iraq.

    AFP fails at their job repeatedly acting as a megaphone for whomever's in power.  In this case, we're dealing with a paranoid tyrant.  AFP sends their stenography out over the wires and, in doing so, does tremendous damage.  The press is supposed to be a watchodg not a stenographer.

    This is the week that saw Nouri (illegally) kick Kurds out of the Cabinet.  For the record, the sectarian strife Nouri's alarmed about at this second is Sunni v. Shi'ite.  But it takes a lot of never when you conduct your war on the Kurds to, in the same week, insist others are playing sectarian games.  Nouri's always been enabled by a slovenly and unprofessional western press.

    In 2010, Nouri agreed to the US-brokered Erbil Agreement.

    Now Nouri's a known liar who's failed to keep every promise he's made in his first and second term.  For those who missed Nouri's first broken promise, he was out of Iraq at the time, and only a few months into being prime minister, when the US began putting up blast walls and barricades throughout Baghdad.  An enraged Nouri insisted they were coming down immediately as soon as he returned to Iraq, he even used the words "promise" in the statement.  Of course, Nouri returned and the walls stayed up.  Add "being Joshua with the rams horns outside the walls of Jericho" to a list of the many things Nouri has tried to be but instead failed miserably at.

    Nouri only agreed to it because he wanted a second term as prime minister and he never planned to honor it.  Other political blocs thought it was for real -- because the US government brokered it and vouched for it -- and signed on.  If Nouri's having trouble and you're an outlet reporting today, you can't ignore The Erbil Agreement.  Since the summer of 2011, Iraqiya (who won in the 2010 elections), the Kurds (Iraqi President Jalal Talabani, KRG President Massoud Barzani, etc) and clric and movement leader Moqtada al-Sadr have been demanding that Nouri stop postponing and implement The Erbil Agreement as he was supposed to at the end of 2010.

    Nouri's failure to implement the contract has disenfranchised many.  When a people stop believing that their voices are listened to, they find means other than conversation to make their points.  What's happening isn't surprising unless you're a stenographer for AFP.   You sort of picture Prahsant Rao and Reider Visser lunching on plain yogurt and lamenting how their thunder thighs will look next weekend in their bridesmaids dresses.



    That's how Iraq arrived at where it is today.

    A lot of liars.


    Over the last few years, a lot of e-mails have come in lamenting tone an language.

    To which I say, you can eat my _____.


    Honestly, tone?

    You're bothered by the tone?

    People are dying and you're bothered that I'm angry that a country supposedly 'liberated' has instead been trashed, decimated and poisoned?


    As for language?

    I've repeatedly noted that I have a very foul mouth.  We are work place friendly.  Which means we are limited to 'swear' words we can use.  My favorite word is four letters long and starts with an "s," ends with a "t" and waves hello via "hi" in the middle.  I can't use that word here.

    I can use "whore" and Media Whores Online pioneered calling out the whores.  I wish MWO was still around.

    But if you can't grasp how much lying and whoring has taken place on Iraq in the last six years, let's note this:


    Alice Fordham has a report for NPR's Morning Edition (link is text and audio) that wants to insist Nouri's trying to bring the Sahwa into the military -- while ignoring what Ned Parker's outlined above and what's taken place for the entire second term of Nouri al-Maliki until right before these elections.
    She's providing a wrong impression to listeners.




    So what, you say, in 2009, Fordham wrongly thought Nouri would incorporate the Sahwa.

    And if that was from 2009 or even 2010, I'd call it out but note that Fordham got it wrong.

    Trouble is, that's from the April 18, 2014 snapshot.

    At that point, at that late date, you're not just 'wrong,' you're whoring because you're deliberately wrong.  (Fordham was deliberately wrong on other details and we noted in that snapshot.)

    Does it matter?

    Does any of it matter?

    It has to.

    Because it's life or death.

    If Alice Fordham had done actual reporting, if Joel Wing and Crazy Reider hadn't whored for thug Nouri, Iraq might not be where it is now, where it is today.

    Violence had dropped off.

    The government in place was imposed by the US government so, political science would argue, there was always a chance of renewed violence when the bulk of US forces left the country.

    So violence could very well have increased.  It could have even gotten worse than it is now.

    But what bred the violence was Nouri al-Maliki.

    And what allowed him to breed the violence was a world that largely looked away, a press that near universally hid the truth -- western press, excuse me -- about what Nouri was doing.

    This is a man so hateful that he sent agents of the Ministry of the Interior into Iraqi schools to target gay and thought to be gay men, to stir up hate against these men, to tell the students that these men would kill them, that these men drink blood, etc.  And not just tell the students that.

    See, here's what got Nouri in trouble, they had a handout.

    When reports first emerged -- in the Iraqi media, please no western outlet touched it -- Nouri's spokesperson insisted the actions of the Ministry were being distorted and nothing of the sort happened.

    But there was the handout.

    And when Alsumaria and Al Mada got a hold of the handout, Nouri's story suddenly changed from it didn't happen to oops how did this happen.

    This is how evil Nouri al-Maliki is.

    He deliberately attempted to frighten children of gay men and encouraged them to attack and kill gay men.

    It was there in the presentation and, too bad for Nouri, it was there in the handout.

    He was evil.

    That's only one example.

    But this is the man that press carried water for.  This is the thug that Joel Wing and Crazy Reider portayed as respectable and a real leader.

    People need to be held accountable for what they do.

    And if that means I have to be the biggest bitch online day after day, then that's what it means for however long this site continues.

    There are a lot of people willing to prop up thugs like Nouri.

    The last six years hasn't seen a lot of attempts -- outside of the Iraqi press -- to defend the people of Iraq.


    This week, the American Kurdish Council of California's Delovan Barawri (at Huffington Post) noted:

    Yet, while the oppressive Middle Eastern regimes subjugated their citizens, especially the minorities, the global players kept a blind eye on the brutality, often supporting and arming the oppressors. A prime example is the Obama administration's support of the former Iraqi Prime Minister, Nuri Maliki, in spite of his dictatorial and marginalizing policies, which ultimately allowed the Sunni regions to turn into breeding grounds for ISIS.



    And that's what all the whoring did.

    It allowed the White House to support Nouri.

    A thug.  Someone who killed protesters.  Someone I believe had a journalist killed (Hadi al-Mahdi).  He certainly had Hadi and other journalists tortured.

    And even when this did get coverage by the western media, it was limited coverage.  (Click here for Annie Gowen and Aziz Alwan covering it for the Washington Post.)

    This is the thug that when the bulk of US forces departed Iraq, turned Iraq's military tanks onto his political rivals.  And Liz Sly reported on it for western media (Washington Post) but people had other things to do apparently.

    So let's not pretend that the Islamic State popped up out of the middle of nowhere and for no reason.

    A lot of whoring allowed the despot Nouri al-Maliki to get away with, yes, murder.

    And the response to that can be seen in Iraq today.


    From time to time, a friend will say to me that they can't believe I called out _____ -- a mutual friend.  Of course I did.  The hurt feelings of a friend don't begin to equal the suffering of the Iraqi people  Those whose actions encourage and prolong the suffering of the Iraqi people probably deserve a little more than hurt feelings over getting roughed up verbally in the global town square that is the internet.

    And maybe instead of whimpering and whining, they could take accountability for their part in increasing violence in Iraq?